What is a short sale?
A short sale is when you sell your house for less than you owe on the mortgage and your lender agrees to accept the lower amount. It may make sense if you're underwater, have a hardship you can document, can't keep the home, and have time to wait for the lender to review it.
Say you owe more on the loan than the house would sell for after costs. Normally you'd have to bring cash to closing to cover the gap. In a short sale, you ask the lender to take less than the full payoff instead.
You can't decide on your own to sell short. The lender reviews your finances, the offer and the value, then says yes, no, or counters. If you have a second loan or a HELOC, that lender generally has to sign off too.
A short sale is not a free pass. You still lose the house. It will likely affect your credit. And depending on your loan, the lender may or may not have a right to come after you for the difference. California has its own rules on that. Before you sign anything, confirm the deficiency question with a real estate attorney, and ask a CPA how a short sale would affect your credit and your taxes.
How do I know if I owe more than my Bakersfield house is worth?
Get a written payoff statement from your lender and compare it to what similar houses near you are actually selling for, minus selling costs. The balance on your monthly statement is not the same as your payoff.
The payoff includes principal, interest, late fees and anything else the lender has added. People are often surprised by it. I worked with a homeowner in Oildale who was caring for a family member full time and wasn't sure of her loan payoff. Fees had pushed her loan balance up over the years.
Once you have your number, add up everything that has to be paid when the house sells:
- The mortgage payoff, plus any second loan or HELOC
- Back property taxes
- Any other liens on the property
- Selling costs like agent commission, escrow and title
- Repairs a retail buyer will likely ask for
Then compare that total to honest sale prices for houses like yours. Not the highest number you've seen online. If the value is higher than the total, you have equity, and a short sale isn't the right tool.
When does a short sale make sense?
A short sale makes sense when you truly owe more than the house can sell for, you can't keep up the payments, and you have a real hardship you can document. It's mostly a way to avoid foreclosure, not a way to get a better deal.
It's usually worth looking at when most of these are true:
- You're underwater after selling costs, not just close to it.
- You have a hardship like a job loss, divorce, medical problems or a move you can't avoid.
- You can't afford to keep the house, and a loan modification or repayment plan isn't working.
- The lender is still willing to review a short sale. Once a house has been sold at foreclosure, that option is generally gone.
- You have months to work with, not days.
Lenders want to see why you can't pay. Expect to send bank statements, tax returns, pay stubs and a hardship letter. If your finances look like you could keep paying, they may say no.
When is a short sale the wrong move?
If you have equity, a short sale makes no sense. Sell the house the regular way or for cash and keep what's left after the loan is paid. It may also be wrong if you can realistically keep the house through a modification or repayment plan.
Being behind on payments does not, by itself, tell you whether you have equity. Compare your payoff and selling costs with the home's likely sale price.
A short sale may also be the wrong move if:
- You can get caught up with help from family or a repayment plan.
- A foreclosure sale is close and the lender won't agree to postpone it.
- You need a firm moving date.
- You have more than one lienholder and one of them won't cooperate.
How long does a short sale take, and will it stop a foreclosure?
Short sales often take months because the lender has to review and approve everything. Starting one does not automatically stop a foreclosure, so ask your lender in writing whether the sale date will be postponed and confirm where you stand with a real estate attorney.
Your file can get passed between departments, and the bank may ask for the same documents more than once. Buyers sometimes walk away while they wait, and then you start over.
Foreclosure runs on its own track. I'm not going to quote you deadlines, because they depend on your loan and where you are in the process. A lender saying it's reviewing your short sale is not the same as a postponed sale date. A HUD-approved housing counselor can help you understand your options too.
If a foreclosure notice is already in your mailbox, read our guide on how to stop foreclosure in Bakersfield. It covers the other options to look at alongside a short sale.
Can I sell a short sale house to a cash buyer like Bakersfield House Buyers?
A cash buyer can make an offer on a short sale, but your lender still has to approve it and sets the pace. A cash sale with equity does not require the lender to accept less than its payoff, so it's a much simpler sale.
When a house has equity, here's how we normally work:
- A cash offer within 24 hours of our first conversation.
- No fees, no commissions and no closing costs for you.
- We buy as-is. No cleanup, no repairs, no showings.
- We can close in as little as 10 days, and you pick the closing date.
One seller in Southwest Bakersfield was behind on property taxes and worried about losing the house. Several dogs had lived inside and there were fleas throughout. We bought it as-is.
Before any sale closes, have a real estate attorney confirm that the price covers your payoff and every lien on the property. In a short sale, I can't promise you speed or a date. If your numbers point to listing with an agent who has closed a lot of short sales, I'll tell you that.
My brother Justin and I have been buying houses in Bakersfield since 2015. People have sold to us because of foreclosure, job loss, divorce, bankruptcy and health issues. We don't use high-pressure sales tactics. I'd rather you make the right call than a fast one.
What should I do first if I think I'm underwater?
Get your payoff statement, find out exactly where you stand with the lender, and talk to a real estate attorney and a CPA about the legal and tax side. Then compare your options side by side.
- Request a written payoff statement from your lender.
- Ask whether a foreclosure has been started and whether a sale date is set.
- Ask what hardship options they offer: modification, repayment plan, short sale.
- Get an honest value from a local agent or from me.
- Talk to a real estate attorney about your foreclosure timeline and whether you could owe the difference. Talk to a CPA about credit and taxes on forgiven debt.
Then write your options next to each other: keep the house, list it, short sale, or sell for cash. The right one is usually obvious once the real numbers are on paper.
If you want a second set of eyes, reach me through bakersfieldhousebuyers.com. Tell me what you owe and what's going on with the house. I'll tell you what I see, even if the answer is a short sale or a listing instead of selling to us.
Frequently asked questions
Will a short sale hurt my credit?
It will likely show on your credit report. How much it affects you compared with a foreclosure depends on your situation, so confirm with a CPA or a real estate attorney before you decide. A HUD-approved housing counselor can also walk you through it.
Do I have to pay taxes on the debt the lender forgives?
Forgiven mortgage debt can be treated as income in some cases, and there are exceptions. Talk to a CPA before you agree to a short sale so you know what to expect.
What if I have a second mortgage or a HELOC?
Generally, each lender with a lien on the house has to agree before a short sale can close. Second lenders often ask for some payment to release their lien, which can slow things down or stop the deal. Confirm how this works for your loans with a real estate attorney.
Can I keep living in the house during a short sale?
Usually you stay in the house until closing. Confirm with your lender and a real estate attorney what's expected of you while the lender reviews the sale.
Can I talk through my numbers with you before I decide anything?
Yes. Reach me through bakersfieldhousebuyers.com and tell me what you owe and what's happening with the house. No pressure either way.
Get a no-obligation cash offer for your house
Tell us about the property and we'll send a fair cash offer within 24 hours. No fees, no repairs, no pressure.
More guides
Cash Offer vs. Listing with an Agent
An honest side-by-side
What Happens at Closing
From offer to payday
